Many churches believe they are doing discipleship because they offer Bible study classes. Scripture is opened. Notes are taken. Discussion is thoughtful. People leave better informed than when they arrived.
And yet something stubborn remains unchanged.
Patterns of life persist. Anxiety lingers. Relationships fracture. Mission feels optional rather than natural. Churches quietly sense that discipleship is happening—but formation is thin.
The problem is not Bible study. Bible study is good, necessary, and irreplaceable. The problem is confusing Bible study with apprenticeship.
Bible study explains the text.
Apprenticeship trains a life.
That distinction matters more than we often admit.
As Christian philosopher Dallas Willard insisted throughout his work, spiritual formation does not happen accidentally. It does not occur simply because information is available or discussion is lively. Formation happens when people are intentionally trained—over time, in community, through practice—to live as Jesus lived.
Spiritual formation in Christ is the process by which people come to actually live as Jesus lived.
Bible study can support that process.
But it cannot replace it.
To read more, fill out the form below.
Spread the wisdom: Share the Church Doctor Report with your fellow ministry leaders and pastors to help them thrive and impact more lives. Let’s grow together!
Rupert Loyd Jr., a United States Navy veteran, has a Bachelor of Arts in history from Miami University in Oxford, Ohio, an MDiv from Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary in Boston, Massachusetts, and a PhD in leadership from Union University in Cincinnati, Ohio. He has over 40 years of pastoral experience in both urban and suburban churches, including multiethnic, multicongregational churches. Throughout his career he has maintained a presence in both the church and the academy. He pastored churches in Luna Pier and Taylor, both in Michigan; Miami, Florida; and Point Place and Toledo, both in Ohio. He taught at Miami Christian College and Trinity College, both in Miami, Florida; Union University in Cincinnati, Ohio; Indiana Wesleyan University in Marion, Indiana; University of Toledo in Toledo, Ohio; and Lourdes University in Sylvania, Ohio.
What if there were a new resource and training network designed to help congregations face current realities with courage, renew their spiritual and missional vitality, and multiply disciples who impact their communities? A network designed to help you carry out an entrepreneurial mission using the unique gifts, skills, and resources God has already provided?
What if this network is available completely free of charge — no membership subscriptions or fees required to participate?
Tell us what you think and express your interest by taking our short survey today!